Claimed relationship: a consensus-seeking, conflict-avoidant ("agreeable"/"mittelmäßig") culture brakes innovation in growing organizations. Tolga Önal argues leadership requires deliberately introducing friction/disagreement rather than optimizing for smooth agreement, using the "disagree and commit" framing: surface real disagreement during debate, but commit fully to the decision once made, rather than defaulting to whichever option avoids conflict.
Treat unanimous, friction-free agreement in a leadership discussion as a possible warning sign rather than a good sign; deliberately invite dissent before a decision, then commit as a team once made.
Tolga Önal cites Andreessen Horowitz's line 'agreeableness kills innovation' as explicit management doctrine at elopage: excessive consensus-seeking in leadership meetings blocks decisive direction-setting. He pushes back on phrases like 'wir treffen uns in der Mitte' ('let's meet in the middle') during leadership discussions, insisting disagreement be resolved by a clear decision followed by full commitment — 'disagree and commit... lass uns disagreen aber lass uns 100% committen.' Team members may voice opposing views before a decision, but once made, everyone commits fully regardless of their original position.