Lore

DTC marketing

How to GROW your Brand's UGC Content with Ryan Babenzien - JolieSkinCo

Ryan Babazian argues that Jolie was built by prioritizing a differentiated product, margin, and profitability over measurable digital performance marketing, using offline, unmeasured tactics and mass creator seeding as the foundation that makes paid spend efficient. He claims measurability does not equal effectiveness, and that founders should challenge industry best practices if their marketing is not driving profit.

Chew On This Podcast - Digestible DTC Content · 2023-06-01 · English

Key ideas

  1. Babazian says a good e-commerce product focuses on vanity, is standard in size (avoiding returns), and builds on a daily habitual behavior. Showering fit this framework, and Jolie is positioned as a beauty-wellness product that treats the water at the source rather than the symptoms.

  2. The video argues that 'unconventional' marketing is how people marketed before the internet because people influence people. Jolie runs offline-first, in-real-life marketing and enhances it with online, and says this differentiates it from peers.

  3. Babazian says that digital is favored because it is measurable, but measurable does not mean good. Facebook's algorithm extracts up to the advertiser's willingness to pay, so brands reliant on it mostly do not make money, and offline unmeasured marketing is what makes paid efficient.

  4. He says cash-flow-dependent, all-digital brands are in a tricky spot because they need immediate return. His advice is to commit about 6 months and up to 45–50% of budget to unmeasured channels, then layer digital, and judge results by blended efficiency (such as MER) and post-purchase surveys rather than direct attribution.

  5. Babazian says seeding product to everyday creators, not just big influencers, beats paid acquisition because cost of goods plus shipping is always less than paid CAC. The priority is content over reach, and the resulting organic content machine lets Jolie spend hundreds of thousands monthly while staying first-purchase profitable.

  6. He says the seeding hit rate is high (about 7 of 10 creators make content) and credits being a category creator with no competition, concluding that the product matters in the end.

  7. Babazian says margin and pricing are controllable levers that first-time founders underrate. Jolie built in extra margin and priced using a proper 500-person survey, which let it survive COVID freight costs and air freight and be profitable within six months.

  8. Having been honest with himself after a VC-backed first company, he says Jolie is explicitly built to sell: limited capital, majority ownership, and fast profitability, creating optionality. He expects a sale window within about 12 months.

  9. The video states that strategic restraint (delaying the rain-shower and handheld versions and product two) keeps the focus on the core product while growth is very high. Retention is exceptional, around 97% over 18 months, because of daily utility, visible results, and a 90-day filter subscription.

  10. His closing takeaway is to rethink how and why marketing budget is allocated: if a measured channel still doesn't drive profit, something is wrong with the channel, and industry best practices are usually bad because they are merely comfortable.

  11. Three-part e-commerce product framework — A screen for good e-commerce products: they focus on vanity, are standard in size, and build on a habitual daily behavior. Apply: Check a product idea against the three criteria; showering met all three and led to Jolie, and standard sizing avoids buy-three-return-one costs.

  12. Offline-first in-real-life marketing — Getting people to talk about the brand at dinners, parties and events first, then enhancing that with online. Apply: Create events and real-world conversation triggers so people discuss the category and the brand, and layer digital on top.

  13. Indirect storytelling events — Brand events that tell a product-relevant story without 'buy' banners, such as a chef cooking with water in different states and an oyster tank demo of East River water filtration. Apply: Design an event around a demonstration that mirrors the product's benefit, such as oysters clearing a tank for a water filter.

  14. Product seeding to everyday creators — Giving product to many creators, even those with 50 followers, to produce honest UGC without measuring direct attribution. Apply: Send product to hundreds of creators weekly, as Jolie does, aiming for content rather than reach, such as seeding 1,000 people over 6 months.

  15. Creator buckets and white-labeling — Loose creator arrangements: some unpaid but welcome to create, some white-labeled with media dollars spent behind their account when organic content performs. Apply: Let creators post freely, then put paid media behind the organic content that performs.

  16. Creator A–F list tiering — Ranking creators from A-list down to F-list, where even F-list creators sell at least one unit. Apply: Seed across all tiers, since each unit sold makes CAC equal to cost of goods plus shipping, which is below paid CAC.

  17. Interest-bucketed manual seeding list and DM outreach — A pre-launch Excel list of 1,200 people grouped by interest rather than followers, contacted via manual DMs. Apply: Build the list by interest, have founders and early hires DM people, and build anticipation so creators prioritize the product.

  18. Vertical expansion of creators — Looking for creators beyond beauty, such as fitness, hair stylists, dog walkers, chefs and artists, since everyone showers. Apply: Ask how the product fits each group's conversation and find a creative way in.

  19. Pre-launch price survey — A 500-person willingness-to-pay and elasticity survey through a professional consumer agency, run in about 10 days for a few thousand dollars. Apply: Survey real consumers rather than biased friends and price toward the top but not at the very top, rather than launching and testing.

  20. Margin buffer — Building as much product margin as possible, and raising price when needed, to absorb unforeseen costs such as freight. Apply: Set margin high before launch; a $4 price increase improves margin overnight.

  21. Non-traditional out-of-home (delivery-truck billboards) — Billboard-carrying delivery trucks in New York, 5 trucks for 4 months. Apply: Use as 'surround sound' awareness at a cost far below Facebook prospecting, and validate through people who saw it.

  22. Sidewalk sticker guerrilla marketing — Funny slogan stickers with a QR code placed outside bars and in high-traffic areas in NYC, LA, Chicago and Miami. Apply: Write slogans that grab the eye, such as comparing shower water to a dirty door handle, so people see the brand name.

  23. Blended-efficiency evaluation of unmeasured channels — Judging offline channels by overall efficiency, such as MER and post-purchase surveys, rather than URL attribution. Apply: Commit about 6 months on blind faith, then check whether MER improved over time and whether surveys mention things like a truck.

  24. Six-month unmeasured-channel commitment — Devoting about 6 months, and up to 45–50% of budget, to unmeasured channels before layering digital. Apply: Start with unmeasured channels, then add digital to make both far more efficient.

  25. First-purchase profitability rule — A spending tolerance that requires ad spend to be profitable on the first purchase. Apply: Keep spending only as long as first-purchase profit holds, supported by organic content.

  26. Community flywheel — Customers become advocates who share content, which brings in new customers. Apply: Get people to talk about the core problem (water) and create content so the flywheel brings in more people.

  27. Build-to-sell playbook — Raising limited capital, owning most of the business, and getting profitable quickly to gain optionality. Apply: Be honest about the desired outcome up front and operate profitably so you can sell whenever you choose.

  28. Strategic restraint — Deliberately delaying new products, such as the rain shower, handheld version and product two, while the core product is growing very fast. Apply: Expand product one with more finishes first, and launch product two only when growth slows.

  29. Subscription filter replacement for retention — A filter that must be replaced about every 90 days, with about 80% of first-time customers subscribing. Apply: Tie daily utility and visible results to a replacement cycle so customers don't remove the product.

  30. Channel profit audit — Reassessing marketing allocation by whether a channel drives profit, not only whether it is measurable. Apply: If a measured channel still isn't driving profit, change the allocation and challenge industry best practices.

Insights

Oysters in East River water tanks were used as indirect storytelling at events, with no 'buy Jolie' banners, tying natural water filtration to Jolie's product.

Babazian says 40% of customers don't know the brand of shower head they are replacing, which leaves white space to own the shower-head brand.

The few thousand dollars spent on the pricing survey is credited with getting Jolie profitable in six months, because a wrong price would have broken the freight price increase.

Delivery-truck billboards and sticker slogans are judged on cost versus Facebook prospecting and 'surround sound' awareness, with QR codes included though nobody expects scans.

Babazian says that even a creator with 50 followers influences those followers more than Facebook influences its 500M users, and about 98% of paid traffic doesn't buy anyway.

Creators are tiered A-list to F-list, and even F-list creators sell at least one unit, making CAC equal to cost of goods plus shipping.

Seeding lists were built manually: an Excel sheet of 1,200 people bucketed by interest rather than follower count, with founders and the first hire sending DMs; now 50–60 inbound creator requests arrive daily.

TikTok's open algorithm lets regular people reach 15M views, which correlated with about 2 hours of 'ridiculous revenue', while Instagram has closed that aperture.

The founder says the shower head is competing for the beauty budget, where women spend $2,500+ yearly, rather than competing with plumbing hardware.

Retention was described as something that 'just happened': 80% of first-time customers subscribe, and churn of 2.3% over 18 months is said to beat Netflix.

«it like hit me like a lightning bolt»

— 06:02

«we do that offline first and then we enhance it with online»

— 10:52

«I can't measure that right and I don't care because I know how we behave as humans»

— 11:54

«Facebook built the most efficient marketing platform in the world for Facebook.»

— 31:49

«Offline non measured stuff supports paid measured stuff.»

— 31:29

«The cost of goods is always less than the acquisition costs on paid.»

— 34:10

«Our tolerance is first purchase profitability, full stop.»

— 36:29

«we're building this to sell»

— 43:47

«it's an exercise and restraint»

— 45:45

«nobody's leaving let's keep providing value»

— 49:16

«if you're prioritizing measurement and you know the measurement is still not driving a profit there's something wrong with the channel»

— 49:59

«your job is to get a profitable business in the end»

— 50:25

Reception

Comments are overwhelmingly warm and appreciative, praising the podcast's insights and value, with only one dismissive, sarcastic outlier.

A tactic-rich founder interview that offers a contrarian, profit-first view of DTC marketing, with specific examples of seeding, out-of-home and pricing research. Its strongest value is the argument that unmeasured offline channels support paid ones.

51:26

↳ Chew On This Podcast - Digestible DTC Content · YouTube

Watch original