Lore

Power-Law Distribution of PM Quality

Overview

Peter Sellis's structural explanation for why most practicing product managers are mediocre: PM skill is likely normally distributed across the population, but once the sample is restricted to people who actually practice PM full-time, the distribution becomes power-law shaped, pulling the median performer well below the mean. Two forces compound this: ZIRP-era hiring made PM roles lucrative for nontechnical people and paid them on the technical career ladder regardless of skill, and — more structurally — the skills that make someone a genuinely great PM transfer so well to founder and executive roles that the best PMs tend to exit the profession entirely rather than remain in it.

"For any power distribution, the median is going to be far below the average. Most people are on the left side of it."

Apply

When benchmarking a role's talent pool, expect the median in-role performer to underperform the mean, and set hiring/promotion bars accordingly rather than anchoring to "average" performance.

Related

Supporting Evidence

Supporting Evidence

Two further data points from Peter Sellis reinforce the power-law/self-selection-out thesis: