Generic reviews at the bottom of the page answer nothing. Proof should answer a question the buyer is already asking, placed where they ask it.
The strength of proof is inversely related to how easy it was to claim.
Sort each hesitation into one of three buckets: the product works, people like me use it, or the company will deliver. Then place proof that took real work at that point:
Related: Brand Moat: Four Pillars of Premium Price Justification.
The strength of a proof element is inversely related to how easy it was to claim. "Third-party tested" costs nothing to type. A restaurant finder with 4,000+ restaurants and zero paid endorsements is something the buyer can verify, so it carries far more weight.
A related signal is warranty specificity. See warranty-specificity-signals-confidence.