Lore

product management

Why half of product managers are in trouble | Nikhyl Singhal (Meta, Google)

Nikhil Singhal argues that AI is turning product management upside down. The 'information mover' PM is becoming obsolete, while builders with judgment are in a renaissance of demand, pay and joy. The transition, which he says will take roughly the next two years, will be exhausting and will require people to reinvent themselves, stay current and find joy in building.

Lenny's Podcast · 2026-04-19 · English

Key ideas

  1. Singhal says the industry is both in a renaissance and under heavy stress. Top builders have record compensation, more offers and paths to founder or C-level roles. Nearly everyone is more exhausted than ever, because skills and practices such as PRDs become obsolete within months.

  2. He says the old PM job was largely moving information between layers of management, which was 'responsibility without authority'. He predicts this information-mover archetype will become a dinosaur, and that about half of product people grew up with that as their superpower.

  3. He says the mechanical parts of building product will be obsoleted within about two years, producing 10–100x more changes to products. Judgment, which he defines as expertise plus wisdom, becomes the scarce skill: deciding what is good, what is worth shipping, and what stays sustainable and differentiated. He also predicts there will be no more bad software, because AI can be told to fix poorly maintained apps.

  4. Singhal predicts a wave of staff shedding followed by rehiring over the next 12–24 months. Companies over-hired, with public companies doubling staff in five years without doubling output, and the rehired staff will be AI-first. He says Lenny's job-market report shows the most open PM roles in 3+ years, and that 'Builders wanted' will be the tagline. Non-builders, who he says are about half of product people, may have to leave tech or build outside it.

  5. Builder-PMs will spread into other functions. Singhal cites 14 founders among about 125 members of his head-of-product community, versus one in its first years, and a senior member interviewing for a CHRO role. He says roles will blur, engineers and designers will move toward product, and PMs will become 'agents of change' who spread across industries like dandelion seeds.

  6. He says the process of building product is changing. Product operating systems will be rebuilt around software, with automated reviews, stand-ups and status reports, and the alignment problem shifts because agents deliver ground truth. Alignment does not disappear, but it loses its 'theatrics'. As Singhal frames it, the aim is to scale yourself through software rather than by hiring humans and management.

  7. Singhal says the human obstacle is psychological. Adults are trained to minimise change, and reinvention feels like a broken deal. Mid-career people have almost no spare time, and the learning target keeps moving. He says those who mastered the old system find reinvention hardest.

  8. He argues that this is a historical pattern. Hardware-era product management was replaced when internet companies arrived, with Google's APM program as an example, and he expects the AI-era chaos to settle again after a couple of years. He says this is not 30 years on an ever-faster merry-go-round, but the moment to get on the boat, and that waiting makes crossing the chasm harder.

  9. Singhal says joy is the main lever. Finding a first-joy moment building something personal turns fear into energy and 'creates time'. His advice is to find joy, raise your pace, make time, swallow your ego about past titles and brands, and take a long-term view. He says people who find all of this boring or nauseating should be honest that they may not be in the industry's next version.

  10. He raises equity and craft concerns. Geography, age, gender and ethnic diversity may take a step back, because the AI wave is Bay Area-centric and demands nights and weekends. He also says design roles are plateauing because the industry conflates 'pixel generators' with 'taste makers', and that engineers, product people and designers each hold a different edge (systems, judgment and communication, taste).

  11. Show and tell — A format at Singhal's monthly heads-of-product meetup where members demo their personal and company AI builds, such as chief-of-staff apps. Apply: Have peers or teams demo what they built with AI so the sharing spreads ideas and creates friendly competition.

  12. Judgment (expertise plus wisdom) — The core future PM skill: deciding whether changes are good, what is worth building or releasing, and what stays sustainable and differentiated. Apply: Focus your role on evaluating and deciding among the many AI-generated changes, rather than moving information.

  13. Obsoleting the mechanical parts / changing the product operating system — Replacing manual product processes such as reviews, stand-ups and status reports with software and agents. Apply: Hire builders with judgment plus people who build internal tools, and automate status reporting and reviews instead of adding staff and management.

  14. Builder vs. information-mover archetypes — A split of product people into those who joined for building (founder types), who are in demand, and those whose strength is moving information and communicating, who are in trouble. Apply: Assess which group you belong to; if you love building, stay current, and if you don't, recognise the industry is moving away from you.

  15. Factory versus car — The old PM maturation model of getting leverage by organising others rather than building yourself ('stop working on the car, work on the factory'), which is now upended. Apply: Recognise that scale can now come from your own opinion and what you build, and rebuild your identity around that.

  16. Shadow superpower — The idea that the better you are at one system, the less likely you are to recognise the new one, so top performers find reinvention hardest. Apply: If you were strong under the old model, deliberately look for the new system instead of assuming your past mastery will carry over.

  17. Equally disappoint everyone (disappointment algorithm) — A description of how people in their 'power years' allocate 6–12 hours against 20 hours of demand, disappointing parents, kids, health, partner and work equally. Apply: Consciously make time to stay current, accepting that you will disappoint others in ways you haven't before.

  18. Crossing the mental threshold — The decision to embrace reinvention and put staying modern above all else, before the chasm gets harder to cross. Apply: Find the reserves and 'activation energy' now, and take comfort in the safety in numbers as many others are going through it.

  19. Green/yellow/red week audit — A test where you colour-code a week of meetings green, yellow and red to see whether your days are draining or energising. Apply: Colour-code your calendar; if it is mostly yellow and red, move toward build mode, which typically shows mostly green and yellow.

  20. First-joy moment — A personal small build with AI tools, such as a partner app, a chief-of-staff inbox app or home-lights control, that turns fear into joy and 'catches the bug'. Apply: Build something small for yourself with Claude Code, Codex or Lovable, and as a leader cultivate and spread such moments in your team.

  21. Obsolete yourself (engineering mindset) — An engineer's habit, learned from a colleague's father, of automating away everything you do, applied with AI agents. Apply: Ask daily what you can obsolete, then have an AI agent do it, and ask what the next agent could be.

  22. Solve your own problem — A tactic of picking a not-great part of your day and telling a coding AI in plain English what you want. Apply: Ask a tool like Claude Code or Lovable for something such as a dashboard to control your Sonos, and be opinionated about what good looks like.

  23. Thrive checklist — Singhal's advice for the next two years: find joy, obsolete yourself, raise your pace, make time, swallow your ego, and stay long-term focused. Apply: Be willing to take a smaller role than your past title if it gets you through the transition, and think of it as being on the boat leaving the station.

  24. The Skip (think the move after next) — The career principle behind Singhal's community name: don't think about the next move, think about the move after. Apply: Use the next couple of years to secure a premier builder role and strong pay, positioning for the move after.

  25. PMs as agents of change / dandelion seeds — A predicted sequence in which product orgs change in about a year, other functions follow about 12 months later, and product leaders spread out to lead that change. Apply: Use your broad organisational view and early access to tools to lead change in other functions and industries.

  26. Edges by role — A view that engineers have the edge in systems thinking and obsolescence, product people in judgment and communication, and designers in taste. Apply: Combine all three strengths, since people with all three do better.

  27. Vibe coding alongside TV — Singhal's habit of vibe coding while watching familiar, structured TV shows. Apply: Pair building with predictable shows, and pick a single AI tool to standardise on to avoid switching costs.

  28. Codifying community tasks as software — Singhal's use of code to replace his manual work, such as matching community members by haves and wants and by who hasn't met, and an agent that finds and matches jobs to a mailing list. Apply: Write software for anything you do manually and can replicate, such as matchmaking, recruiting or answering repeat questions.

  29. LLM disagreement write-up — A feedback loop where an AI trained on Singhal's content answers audience questions, and he reviews the answers, spots themes and writes up where the LLMs and he disagree. Apply: Train an AI on your content, evaluate its answers, and use the disagreements as material.

  30. Gift 30 days free (viral plus enablement) — A growth idea for winning back people who tried an early version of a product and turned it off, using a referral plus a friend's endorsement. Apply: Let users gift a free trial period to friends who dropped the product, so they can try it again and then subscribe.

  31. Agents trained on many community leaders — Singhal's skip.help product, which answers questions using agents trained on about 50 community leaders. Apply: Ask it about interview prep, navigating your environment, or how to build a chief-of-staff app, to get 'wisdom of the crowds' rather than one person's view.

Insights

Singhal says the fear of change drowns out the fact that what is changing is mostly the parts of the job people did not love, such as status reports, ticket grooming and alignment theatre.

On his account, brand names on a resume matter less than how modern your delivery is. Interviews are moving to scenarios about tools, judgment and thinking, and a big-brand résumé can hurt if the company is not seen as AI-forward.

He argues that the 'shadow superpower' means top performers under the old system have the least incentive to change, because their employers see them doing great.

He says a builder-PM should not act as the '51st engineer' on a 50-person team, which he calls a 'cheap knockoff of an engineer', and should instead build tools that help them stay on top of the team's work.

Singhal says alignment used to be largely a problem of getting people ground-level truth. A CEO can now ask an agent what a customer wants or how a change affects the system, though someone still has to decide what to fight for.

He predicts that within 5 years the vast majority of listeners will be in a different job, either by choice or because their company sheds and rehires.

He bets that 80% of PMs today would say no to their boss's boss's day of back-to-back meetings, and expects that answer to change within two years.

He says the way in for non-engineers is opinion, not systems skill: after watching his non-engineer wife get value from AI tools, he concluded you only need to be opinionated about what you want and know what good looks like.

He frames the AI-era 'genius is 1% inspiration, 99% perspiration' as AI doing the perspiration while inspired individuals proliferate.

The Tesla anecdote reflects the same theme as the conversation: he found a mild driving anxiety that self-driving removes, and his stated rule is to eliminate anxiety sources where possible. He also suggests a growth tactic of gifting 30 free days of self-driving to friends who turned it off.

«The information mover is essentially going to become a dinosaur.»

— 00:17

«The builders are going to have the time of their lives, but if you don't love building stuff, you're in trouble.»

— 00:51

«I think there won't be any more bad software.»

— 16:56

«Builders wanted is going to be the big tagline for the next couple of years.»

— 26:22

«Right now if it's manual, we're cooked.»

— 33:25

«Your brands don't matter as much as how modern you are in your ability to deliver product.»

— 37:22

«Your goal when you're in your power years is to equally disappoint everyone in your life.»

— 44:14

«The ones that mastered the old game find it the hardest to go through this reinvention stage.»

— 45:44

«My job is not to move information. My job is to evaluate.»

— 51:48

«Joy is the biggest antidote to burnout.»

— 56:22

«An engineer is someone who obsoletes themselves from everything they do.»

— 61:29

«There is a world which is better, but I have to go through the tunnel, and the tunnel sucks.»

— 64:30

«It's smiling exhaustion.»

— 80:48

Reception

Mostly warm and appreciative, with viewers saying the conversation resonated and felt honest, but a sizable minority pushed back with skepticism about AI hype, fear-mongering, and the value of PMs and 'vibe coding'.

An energetic, opinionated interview that pairs a bold market thesis (builders and judgment over information movers) with practical, emotionally candid advice on reinvention. Its predictions are asserted more than evidenced, and its most durable value is the reinvention playbook.

95:11

↳ Lenny's Podcast · YouTube

Watch original